Politicspoliticsthreejudgepaneltexasredistricting

Thu Apr 20, 2017, 07:35 PM

Federal Court: Texas Intentionally Gerrymandered Its Districts to Dilute Minority Votes [View all]

A couple of weeks ago the three judge panel found that Texas intentionally discriminated in the drawing of Congressional Districts. Today the court ruled that Texas also intentionally discriminated in the drawing of state house districts http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slatest/2017/04/20/federal_court_rules_texas_gerrymandered_districts_to_dilute_minority_votes.html

On Thursday, a three-judge federal court ruled that Texas intentionally discriminated against minority voters in drawing its state House district map in 2011. The decision follows a similar ruling by the same court in March holding that Texas also drew its federal congressional districts in an effort to dilute minority votes. Thursday’s ruling marks the third time in recent weeks that the federal judiciary has found Texas to have intentionally burdened its Hispanic voters.

The majority attached a 151-page findings of fact to its already lengthy opinion, reflecting careful analysis of Texas’ gerrymander that will be difficult for the Supreme Court to ignore on appeal. In short, the court found that Texas legislators drew multiple House districts that diluted Hispanics’ votes, a violation of both the Voting Rights Act and the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. The court also found that the legislature had engaged in race-based gerrymandering, which similarly runs afoul of equal protection and the VRA. Finally, the court concluded that the House map violated the one person, one vote principle by creating districts within unequal populations, another Equal Protection infringement.

Most critically, the majority held that Texas legislators had intentionally gerrymandered these districts in an effort to discriminate against Hispanics. That finding is key: If upheld, it means the court can place Texas back under “preclearance,” which would allow the Justice Department to veto all voting-related changes before they take effect. The Supreme Court gutted preclearance in 2013, but courts can still apply it to states that have been found to engage in deliberate voting discrimination. And although Attorney General Jeff Sessions is likely to sign off on whatever voter suppression measures Texas passes over the next few years, a future Democratic administration could preemptively halt future Texas laws.

Texas will appeal this decision, along with others invalidating its districts and voting laws, all the way to the Supreme Court if necessary. Civil rights advocates are nervous about their odds at the high court, where they’ll need the support of Justice Anthony Kennedy, who sometimes favors states’ rights to suppress the franchise. But thanks to Thursday’s comprehensive decision, Kennedy will, at the very least, have to grapple with hundreds of pages of proof that Texas’ absurdly gerrymandered districts are the product of legislative racism.
I have had fun this afternoon reading and enjoying the 171 page opinion and the 151 page Findings of Fact.

Texas is headed towards being bailed in under the Voting Rights Act. This is a very tight opinion that focuses only on the major violations that can be showed to be due to racial discrimination. The court found a ton of violations even using this type standard.

I am awaiting to see how many house seats may be flipped from GOP to Democratic control due to the ruling.

61 replies, 3856 views

Reply to this thread

Back to top Alert abuse

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 61 replies Author Time Post
Reply Federal Court: Texas Intentionally Gerrymandered Its Districts to Dilute Minority Votes [View all]
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 OP
Shkreli Apr 2017 #1
StateUsernameHere Apr 2017 #5
Shkreli Apr 2017 #7
StateUsernameHere Apr 2017 #9
Moe Zarella Apr 2017 #19
Generically Speaking Apr 2017 #31
Moe Zarella Apr 2017 #33
Generically Speaking Apr 2017 #34
Moe Zarella Apr 2017 #37
Generically Speaking Apr 2017 #38
Moe Zarella Apr 2017 #39
Generically Speaking Apr 2017 #41
Moe Zarella Apr 2017 #51
Nostrings Apr 2017 #49
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #29
Shkreli Apr 2017 #40
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #43
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #2
Dumper Apr 2017 #3
Generically Speaking Apr 2017 #35
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #4
John Q Citizen Apr 2017 #6
Shkreli Apr 2017 #8
John Q Citizen Apr 2017 #10
Shkreli Apr 2017 #11
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #17
i verglas Apr 2017 #12
John Q Citizen Apr 2017 #15
i verglas Apr 2017 #16
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #21
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #18
i verglas Apr 2017 #23
John Q Citizen Apr 2017 #26
i verglas Apr 2017 #30
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #28
i verglas Apr 2017 #32
Valishin May 2017 #53
i verglas May 2017 #54
Valishin May 2017 #55
MeatSandwich Apr 2017 #13
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #20
Carl Apr 2017 #24
TexMex Apr 2017 #25
Carl Apr 2017 #27
TexMex Apr 2017 #42
Letmypeoplevote May 2017 #59
MeatSandwich Apr 2017 #44
Letmypeoplevote May 2017 #58
MeatSandwich May 2017 #60
fszwfnj Apr 2017 #14
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #22
Lifelong Apr 2017 #36
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #47
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #45
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #46
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #48
Letmypeoplevote Apr 2017 #50
Letmypeoplevote May 2017 #52
Letmypeoplevote May 2017 #56
Letmypeoplevote May 2017 #57
kevlar May 2017 #61

Politicspoliticsthreejudgepaneltexasredistricting